"Thank you for an amazing dinner tonight! My husband and I are visiting from Carleton Place, Ontario, Canada and were told about your restaurant by our hotel. They were right! The best Italian food I have had in years!" - Brenda Mattey
Buy a Large Pizza from Stefano's Pizzeria and 
Receive a "Pizza Card". Return 10 cards and
Receive One Large Plain Pizza FREE!

Get Free Pizza!

"I got a smiley face on my pizza box....what a nice touch! Keep up the great work!" - Brad G. (Facebook)



Recent Visits & Pics

Have you enjoyed our dining areas recently? Send in a picture and get a FREE order of knots :) Email your pictures to stefanospizza@hotmail.com

Banquets & More...

Just call us at 315.493.0400 and we will deliver your order hot and fresh!

We deliver to Carthage, West Carthage, Champion, Denmark, Great Bend, Deferiet, Herrings and more...

and if your order is above $150.00 we will deliver almost anywhere!

We Deliver!



258 State Street - Carthage, New York


• Mon - Thu: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
• Fri - Sat: 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
• Sun: 3:00 pm - 10:00 pm

Copyright Stefano's Pizzeria. All rights reserved.

Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Stefano's offers a private Banquet Room for all your special events: Wedding Receptions, Birthdays, Retirement, Promotion, and more. Stefanos can also cater your next event with a large selection of Italian dishes sure to please your guest. 

Make your next event one to remember with Stefanos

New Location Coming Soon!

"Great food and good people!! This has become my "hometown pizzeria"!!! "- Gary French

Our Three Locations...

Small Cheese Pizza & 10 Wings:

Large Cheese Pizza, 20 Wings & Large Antipasto:

Stefano's gift cards make the perfect gift! Available in any amount, they are sure to bring a smile to anyone for any special event. Stop-in and ask about our Gift Cards.
We love to share photos and stories of people enjoying themselves at our restaurants. Send us your “Stefano’s Experience”!




"Best food around.  Best pizza around.  I come home once a year and its a must eat on day one."- Toby Spencer

"Awesome awesome Awesome!" - Al Countryman 

A "Taste" of  What Our

258 State Street

Carthage, New York

24 Cut Pizza & 50 Wings:

Gift Cards...

3852 Rt. 13
Pulaski, New York

3292 Main Street
Mexico, New York


Pizza Specials

Large Cheese Pizza & 30 Wings: 

New location opening September/ October of 2017!  Serving: Black River, Fort Drum and surrounding areas!


"Steffano has perfected Italian Food, I have loved it since the very early days in the 80's when I was too young to appreciate it. Every time we dine with them you can tell the attention to detail that goes into every dish he has on the menu. No wonder Steffano's has grown into a beautiful dynasty, that just keeps growing. We have had family dine there from all over the country and they agree, it is the best food period. May you and your family grow and prosper Steffano, you are the American Dream."

- JonPaul Vanier


Customers are Saying......